Indi has a few favourite toys that she enjoys playing with. I try to rotate her toys that she doesn't get bored of them. Once they are tossed under the stove, they will stay there for some time, until I clean, then put them away for a bit.
Indi is a huge fan of these cat nip toys by Yeowww! I purchased a fish shaped one first, for her birthday one year. Then this little crinkle toy ladybug. She loves them both. I have purchased other catnip toys in the past which she wasn't a huge fan of, so I would highly recommend these toys for your cat.
Indi's Review: 5 out of 5
My review: same!
I honestly have nothing bad to say about these toys. They are durable. She plays with them often. I will likely purchase a few more in different shapes in the future.